She was nude, beaten, and her clothes were scattered around her. Jan. 11, 1992 David Sharff, 37, shot. The most intriguing clue, however, came from Wileys office typewriter. Duprees first trial ended in a hung jury, and he was acquitted the second time around. To this day, there have been no leads and no suspects, but there have been a number of other missing and murdered women in Lumberton whos disappearances and deaths continue to be unsolved. He had been shot in the forehead, and his gun was found near his right hand. She had been struggling with a heroin addiction and, like the other women, was finally trying to get clean. For years, the people behind the crime remained a mystery. On the morning of April 14, 1972, New York Police Department officers Philip Cardillo and Vito Navarra responded to a call for assistance from Detective Thomas of the 28th Precinct. The call originated from the second floor of Mosque Number 7 in Harlem, the New York headquarters of the Nation of Islam. 1995. Edit Edit source History Talk (0) Trending pages. list of unsolved murders between 1972 and 2000 in Fayetteville and Cumberland On April 17th, 2017, Rhonda was supposed to have a court date to get visitation. She hasnt been seen or heard from since and her body has never been found. Oct. 2, 1993 Joe McAlister, unknown age, shot. Their deaths are listed with undetermined causes and havent been listed as homicide. Her mom called her multiple times without getting an answer and by that night her calls were going straight to voicemail. In 1988, Captain Michael OMara was nearing the end of a highly decorated career with the Cook County Sheriffs Police Department in Chicago. And that is, our investigation, is to determine who did that. I aint gonna stop fighting. Megan wouldnt talk to the police though. From the looks of it, his body hadnt, EARLY LIFE: Katherine Ktie Memory Jones was born in Asheville, North Carolina on December 19, 1989. Its been theorized that Jones could have been killed while interrupting a drug transaction. home as she slept on Oct. 20, 1994. But, I will say I do believe that we have promising evidence. While researching the Coniff case for his masters thesis, Bamonte made some surprising discoveries. Making Lumberton the most diverse city in North Carolina. All three deaths were ruled to be suicides, even though there was no gun found at one of the scenes! Oct. 27, 1983 Human remains, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Frederick Robert Klenner Jr. Frederick Rober Klenner Jr. was considered a mass murderer who killed several victims between 1984 and 1985. The fact that weve done so many interviews. Like Herbert Schirmer, Godfrey agreed to undergo regression hypnosis and described meeting with alien beings inside a spacecraft. I might rest a little while, but I wont never stop., Its killing me. Gainor was also clutching a leather bag containing several items, including some custom-made silk shirts. This is one of the most frustrating to understand. The Chilling Disappearance of Brianna Maitland. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. Inside the cabinet was a nude and decomposing body that had been covered by a blanket. February 3, 1972 Boone, North Carolina Three members of the Durham family are killed and left draped over the edge of their bathtub On the night of February 3, Troy Hall received a phone call from a voice he didn't recognize. If you have information about this case or any unsolved case in North Carolina, please contact the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation, (800) 334-3000. The fact that weve done so many interviews. shot to death in the front seat of a car on Caledonia Circle off McLamb Drive May 21, 1993 Joann Harris, unknown age, shot. May 7, 2019 . Kelvin McMillian, 28, of 1103 Madonna He is also the co-owner of a pop culture website called The Back Row and recently wrote the award-winning script for a short film called Indefinite Late Fee. Area: 701 North Tryon Street, #413 . to keep expanding and making Murderpedia a better site, but we really Wiley even claimed he had been working on a novel, but investigators could never find any manuscript for it. Doyle Wheeler was called on to testify and claimed that Jacobs did have a history of racism and misconduct. new content, we kindly appreciate any donation you can give to help If you have information about this caseor any unsolved case in North Carolina, please contact the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation,(800) 334-3000. After knocking, she entered the apartment to find her daughter dead. For comparison, Pinehurst (1.5 hours away) the crime rate is 69.7% lower than the national rate and 72.5% lower than the North Carolina crime rate. FBI special agent John Strong said, We owe it to each of these women, we owe it to their families, we owe it to this community to put together the pieces of the puzzle and to provide the answers of what happened in it.. He had been shot. Most people consider this case closed, so we may never know the truth. On the evening of May 30, OMara told his family that he was going out to buy some frozen yogurt. Angela Rothen. Nov. 20, 1990, David Mack, 39, shot Medical Center after a man walked into his business on July 31, 1989, and shot One of the big ones was that the rape kits from the bodies werent submitted for over a year and a half. Feb. 9, 1984 William McKoy, unknown age, handgun. was robbed and stabbed to death by two men in the 800 block of Hillsboro Street Where Pinehurst is the mecca of golf (where the PGA has been held and is home to the number 2 golf course) with a high population of wealthier households of doctors and other specialists, Lumbertons population is much more disadvantaged. July 24, 2003 Walter Jones, 54, shot. Sheriff John Montgomery said agents with the U.S. Marshal's . Updated: Feb 28, 2023 / 09:41 PM EST. He has been a guest speaker on numerous national radio and television stations and is a five time published author. During the Great Depression, these were considered valuable commodities for criminals who dealt in black-market food. She grew up in Pembroke only 12 miles from Lumberton with her 2 sisters. Sept. 17, 1974 Sidney Shannon, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Nov. 17, 1977 James Shifflett, unknown age, unknown cause of death. [2] The notoriety behind Godfreys story eventually forced him to resign from the police force, but he continues to maintain that the events actually happened. David Jackson D.O.H. date of the murder, the name of victim(s), their age and how they were killed. A case is defined as cleared when an arrest is made or there is an exception, such as a suspected killer being dead or incarcerated for another crime. She was lying on the ground outside her truck with a gunshot wound to the back of the head, and her gun was resting near her right hand. In fact, only months later, the body of 28-year-old Megan Ann Oxendine would be found nude in the yard of another abandoned home in the same 4 block radius. Location: Rt 1 Box 487 Oak Ridge (NC 68 south of NC 150) Summary: Victim was found fatally stabbed inside Jack's Gas Mart Ollie Christine Ledbetter Case #: 83 0323 001 Date: March 23, 1983 Location: Rt 3 Summerfield (NC 150 west of US 220) Summary: Victim was found fatally stabbed inside Ledbetter Grocery Charles James Hondros Jr While there was indeed a Detective Thomas who worked at the 28th Precinct, he never made the call for assistance, which was likely a trap to lure officers to the mosque and incite a confrontation. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Sept. 13, 1964 Terry and Alan Westerfield, unknown ages, un known cause of If you have information about this caseor any unsolved case in North Carolina, please contact the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation,(800) 334-3000. View history Sherry E. Lyall (February 1959 - January 15, 1984; later Sherry Hart) was an American mother and murder victim. The problem is exacerbated when broken down by demographics. However, because the area is small and people know each other, people in the area knew who the body in the trash can was. One of those people was Megan Oxendine. During the melee, Officer Cardillo was shot with his own service revolver by an unknown assailant. She took, DISCOVERY: John Doe was discovered on May 13, 1977 after a wildlife officer found the burlap sac hed been wrapped in snagged on the banks of the Brunswick River, just south of the US Route 74 and US Route 76 bridge, in Leland, Brunswick County, North Carolina. found dead on Feb. 7, 1981, in a wooded area near his home. Found inside the home were her two daughters, ages 4 and 18 months. July 22, 1989 Carolyn Faye Smith, unknown age, unknown cause of death. At this time it was the most dangerous city in North Carolina. Nov. 14, 1993 Nathan Turner, 14, shot. She was a sickly newborn who many believed wouldnt live past the age of one, but she did. Faith Hedgepeth was a UNC sophomore when she was killed on Sept. 7, 2012. By the time of his trial, there was an overwhelming amount of evidence connecting Pittman to these killings, including that he hired Taraha Nicholson less than a week before she was found dead. Nathaniel ``Buddy`` Marshall, 46, of You hear every cop saying, We cant do better because they dont cooperate,' Skaggs said, But these young cops dont know how to talk to people and get them to cooperate.. Rhondas autopsy showed much of the same findings. utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including If you have information about this case or any unsolved case in North Carolina, please contact the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation, (800) 334-3000. 1993 Unknown male, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Shes just quiet. Her murder was unsolved until Sept. 16, 2021, when Chapel Hill police made an arrest in her case. I think you were able to truly portray your interest in the topic through your blog and were cognizant of the sentiments attached to such like stories. The fact that we have consulted with so many different departments. If you do a youtube search for the police audio . June 30, 1990 Shelby Williams, 32, strangulation. After an extensive second investigation, the controversial suicide ruling was finally overturned in December 2013, and Joness cause of death was changed to undetermined. However, the exact circumstances of what happened remain a mystery. There is a growing disconnect in many major cities between police and the community they serve, especially in the African American communities in the aftermath of events like the murder of George Floyd, Hargrove said. CrimeStoppers pays cash for information leading to arrests in felony cases and callers never have to identify themselves. Because of a lack of proof, however, it still begs the question: Was Antwan Pittman really responsible for the deaths of all of these women? Your email address will not be published. If you have information about this case, call the Kernersville Police Department (336) 996-3177. Megan Oxendines family has been the most outspoken so we have more information on her, but heres what we know about Christina Bennett. Shelby Williams, 32, of 620 Campbell Im not giving up. March 11, 1979 Rooneycq Harris, unknown age, unknown cause of death Feb. 24, 1984 Adrian Walker, unknown age, unknown cause of death. When police spotted him in Greensboro in June 1985, they knew he was dangerous. The officers showed up at the little blue house with boarded up windows and upon entering the house found that there were still pieces of furniture left behind. The ghost apparently takes one look over its shoulder before vanishing. While Megan was also naked, she was lying on top of her shirt. In 1999, Davina Buff Jones was a 33-year-old rookie working for the police department at Bald Head Island, North Carolina. Instructions; List of Templates; in: United States. Sheila Price said, I didnt get to bury my baby. While Joness death was initially believed to be a homicide, it was officially ruled a suicide two weeks later. Darlene Tilley's unsolved murder is currently the oldest unsolved murder in North Carolina history. He never returned home and was found dead at a service area near the Markham Courthouse. Rebecca Ann Thompson, 17, of 224 Multiple agencies, including the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation, the Boone Police Department, the Georgia Bureau of Investigation and the Appalachian State University Police Department, were also involved in the case. on May 3, 1986. system, without permission from Dr. Maurice Godwin. Around 6 PM, Abbys mom called the police to report Abby missing. She was too decomposed. When investigators checked Wileys apartment, there were no signs of foul play. Shortly thereafter, two sets of keys were found inside the stores closet. CCIT falls under the Field Operation Division of the SBI and is responsible for assisting local and federal law enforcement investigations with unresolved homicides, missing persons and unidentified individuals in the state. More than 30 years later, Fisher's estranged wife was charged with first-degree murder. Police had plans to follow up with Megan about her attack, but they didnt get the chance. We are still putting forth the same amount of, effort. After that, the investigation into Elwood Gainors murder hit a complete standstill. A cold case went unsolved for more than a decade, and now a former North Carolina soldier is charged with murder. On March 19, 2004, Brianna Maitland closed out her shift at the Black Lantern Inn around 11:20 P.M. and climbed into her car. B Street on Oct. 28, 1985. July 5, 1999 Maricia Rice, 30, handgun. Brenda Melvin, 25, of 1410 Pamalee We are putting a lot of effort into finding out who placed them they are. News | fayobserver.com, Family of Woman Found Dead in Lumberton 4 Years Ago Takes Up Cause of all Missing and Murdered in the City | insideedition.com, Families of women whose bodies found 3 years ago plead for help | robesonian.com, FBI, police search for clues in deaths of 3 Lumberton women 4 years later; $40K reward offered | wbtw.com, Lumberton, North Carolina, Where 3 Women Mysteriously Died Last Year, Has Sordid History of Violence | insideedition.com, Pinehurst, NC Crime Report, 2021 | homesnacks.com, Most Dangerous Cities in NC | newsovserver.com, Jensen & Holes | The Murder Squad Podcast. Oct. 28, 1985 Richard Northup, 45, blunt force. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. After Megans body was found, the Lumberton Police Department knew they needed help and called in the FBI. Weve had analysts working this. At the time of her death, Deborah was 40 years old and the mother of a son. In spite of an extensive investigation, the full truth behind the alleged attack on Doyle Wheeler was never uncovered. She has the name Chris tattooed on her chest. Rhonda Jones mother, Sheila Price has a memorial near where her daughters body was found. Bryce Durham, 51, his wife, Virginia, 44, and their son, Bobby, 18, were found dead in their home duringa snowstorm Feb. 3, 1972, in a chilling attack that became locally known as the Durham Case.. Despite this, he plead not guilty, but was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without parole for her death. April 12, 1984 Daniel Callahan, unknown age, unknown cause of death. His grandparents house was just a few miles from where several of the bodies were found. She didnt really mess with too many peopleI dont understand how people could do somebodys child, mother, niece like that. In this interview, Megan had a black backpack on her back. Dec. 11, 1981 Brad William Smith, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Dec. 1, 1977 Dennis Bown, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Last updated: May 11, 2009, North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation2023, North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation. This report was never properly followed up, but after reopening the investigation and interviewing some witnesses, Bamonte came to believe that this allegation might be true. The purpose of the group is to raise awareness for the deaths of these 3 women, but also for all the other unsolved murders in Robeson County. Feel free to contact him here. Witnesses identified the mosques school dean, Louis 17X Dupree, as Cardillos shooter, but due to political pressure, it would be two years before Dupree was indicted for murder. Richard W. Northrup, 45, of Box 2852, May 3, 1986 Jerry McKoy, 8, knife. Cold Case Files. He had been beaten and shot in the head four times. ), As of April of 2021, there are still no suspects of solid leads, but reportedly they have some new evidence. George Aug. 20, 1974 Denise King, unknown age, unknown cause of death. Since there was no evidence of robbery or struggle, OMaras death was ruled to be a suicide. She didnt really mess with too many peopleI dont understand how people could do somebodys child, mother, niece like that.. During the 1980s, Anthony Bamonte became the sheriff of Pend Oreille County. Cumberland County Sheriff's Office. Dec. 4, 1981 Unknown remains, unknown age, unknown cause of death. In the relatively small town of Lumberton, North Carolina women have been turning up dead without an explanation and without a suspect. The last confirmed sighting of him took place on July 28, 1985. He had been beaten. No part of this may be reproduced or March 14, 1983 Frankie Horsely, unknown age, unknown cause of death. (Also the last place Cynthia was seen. OMaras car was parked at a gas tank, and his body was slumped over a rock on the nearby lawn. Davis, 81, who is believed to be the only surviving perpetrator, is in a correctional facility in Augusta, Georgia. I promise you, its killing me. There was not enough physical evidence to link him to the other murders, but they did stop after he was taken into custody, so it is very likely that he was indeed the Edgecombe County Serial Killer. Last updated: May 11, 2009, North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation2023, North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation. Two days later, his abandoned station wagon was found at Lakefront State Park in Cleveland. When Rhonda Jones body was found, Megan was interviewed by the local news. Valdosta, Ga., was found beaten to death in a vacant lot off Person Street near I know I also speak for the entire Watauga County community when I say that we will never forget to keep the Durham family in our thoughts and prayers, he added. Required fields are marked *. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. The caller spoke in hushed tones and identified herself as his mother-in-law, Virginia Durham. (NewsNation) The murder clearance rate hit an all-time low in 2020, and data analyzed by a nonprofit shows that trend continued last year. These items were eventually traced to Joe Deano, a New York mobster who was heavily involved in bootlegging. All three women struggled with drug addiction and drugs would be found in their systems upon autopsy. found dead in his apartment on Feb. 17. If you come across them, do not attempt to apprehend them yourself. Kristin Bennett, Lumberton Police told the medical examiner to discard of the blanket she was wrapped inI didnt even finish high school, but I have enough common sense to think, when doing a murder investigation, that may have evidence., In the autopsy report for Christina Bennett it reads: The grey blanket is disposed of at the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner at the request of law enforcement.. AUTOPSY: An autopsy was performed upon the body being brought, The Disappearance of Nguyet Thu Wiki Phung, Case Update: Brittanee Drexels Remains Discovered After 13 Years, Suspect Charged, The Disappearances of Tina & Bethany Sinclair. Four years. It was later determined that they were Mayfords backup keys. The fact that we have consulted with so many different departments.